Cover This PetCompare

Compare

Lemonade vs Embrace vs Trupanion

Eligibility and product shape, not a ‘winner.’ Fetch, Pets Best, and Spot are in the second table. We do not invent prices, star ratings, or claim-payout times.

The three named in the URL

LemonadeEmbraceTrupanion
New enrollment agePublic pages say you can enroll from two months old. Upper enrollment age is breed- and state-specific (third-party reviews cite 10 or 14). A Lemonade city page notes a 13-year-old dog might be declined due to age. Verify on the quote form and the issued policy. Terms vary by state.Puppies from 6 weeks. Dogs up to 14 can enroll in accident-and-illness. Dogs 15+ can enroll in accident-only. Already insured pets can continue for life, per Embrace’s dog-insurance page.Trupanion’s quote form states you can enroll pets up to 14 years old. Trupanion’s eligibility FAQ (retrieved via public search Aug 2026; a later direct fetch was blocked by Trupanion’s CDN): cats and dogs under 14 are eligible; pets enrolled before the 14th birthday keep coverage for life. Pets 14 and over cannot newly enroll.
Waiting periodsLemonade’s waiting-period guide (fetched Aug 2026): 0 days for accidents, 14 days for illnesses, 30 days for orthopedic conditions. Policy effective 12:01 a.m. the day after purchase. Preventative-care packages, if purchased, start when the policy activates. Some states use different waits — Verify on the quote form and the issued policy. Terms vary by state.Embrace’s waiting-period page: 14-day illness wait; accident coverage starts on the policy effective date. Orthopedic waits vary by state. Embrace help articles and sample terms describe a 180-day (6-month) orthopedic wait for dogs, sometimes reducible with a vet orthopedic exam. Verify on the quote form and the issued policy. Terms vary by state.Trupanion’s US public FAQ pages we successfully fetched do not publish a single nationwide waiting-period number. Waiting periods are state-specific. Do not rely on Australian Trupanion pages for a US policy. Verify on the quote form and the issued policy. Terms vary by state.
Pre-existingNot covered. A pre-existing condition is any issue the pet showed signs of, was diagnosed with, or was treated for before the waiting period ended. Pets with pre-existing conditions can still be insured; related bills are not reimbursed.Not covered. Embrace defines a pre-existing condition as any injury, illness, or irregularity noticed by you or your veterinarian before the end of the waiting period, even if the pet never saw a vet for it.Not covered. Trupanion’s US FAQ: a pre-existing condition is any illness, condition, or injury for which signs or evidence of potential manifestation existed within the 18 months prior to the effective date or applicable waiting periods. Recurrence of a prior injury is also pre-existing. Eligibility for a specific condition cannot be determined until a claim is submitted.
Curable pathIn most states Lemonade describes a 12-consecutive-month symptom- and treatment-free path for some temporary conditions. Knee/ligament conditions and chronic conditions (examples Lemonade lists: arthritis, allergies, asthma, cancers, endocrine diseases) cannot be ‘cured’ under that rule.Curable vs incurable: Embrace lists diabetes and allergies as examples of incurable pre-existing conditions. Ear infections and undiagnosed vomiting or diarrhea are examples of curable issues that may be eligible after 12 months symptom-free. Bilateral conditions (hip dysplasia, cruciate tears): if one side is pre-existing, the other side is not covered.Trupanion’s US FAQ example: allergies diagnosed as a puppy remain excluded even after years without symptoms. Trupanion does not describe a 12-month ‘cured’ path on the US pre-existing FAQ we fetched. A hip-dysplasia example was covered when Trupanion found a medical disconnect from an old sprain. We do not treat ACL/cruciate as curable on Trupanion based on that page.
Accident-onlyLemonade’s public pet pages describe accident-and-illness as the base plan, with optional preventative-care packages. We did not find a standalone accident-only product on the pages we fetched. Verify on the quote form.Yes, for pets 15+ (and as a basic option). Embrace’s FAQ: $5,000 annual reimbursement, $100 deductible, 90% reimbursement — those parameters are not flexible. Covers events such as bloat, foreign-body ingestion, hit-by-car, poisoning, lacerations.Trupanion’s public US pages we reviewed describe a medical insurance product (injury and illness) with no annual limit in marketing copy. We did not verify a separate accident-only plan. Verify on the quote form.
WellnessOptional Preventative Care Packages. Lemonade says those benefits can be used as soon as the policy activates (no wait).Optional Wellness Care / Wellness Rewards — a non-insurance membership plan, not available standalone. No waiting period for routine care with Wellness Rewards, per third-party summaries; confirm on the quote form.Trupanion does not market a wellness/preventive add-on on the pages we compared (Fetch’s public comparison states Trupanion does not offer wellness coverage). Verify on the quote form.
9yo Frenchie + prior ACL

Nine is under many published 10/14 caps, but Lemonade’s upper age is breed- and state-specific. Run the quote form.

A prior ACL/cruciate is a ligament condition. Lemonade says knee/ligament conditions cannot use the 12-month ‘cured’ path.

Nine is under 15, so accident-and-illness enrollment is the product Embrace describes for this age. Still run the quote.

Prior ACL is a bilateral ligament condition. Embrace: if one side is pre-existing, the other side is not covered.

Under 14, so the quote form should accept the age. Run it.

A documented ACL is an injury with signs before the effective date. Trupanion’s own allergy example shows long-quiet chronic issues staying excluded.

Official quoteGet a quote from LemonadeGet a quote from EmbraceGet a quote from Trupanion

What actually differs (without ranking them)

  • Age gate: Trupanion stops new enrollment at 14. Embrace switches 15+ to accident-only. Lemonade’s upper cap is breed/state — verify.
  • Orthopedic wait: Lemonade publishes 30 days. Embrace often 180 days for dogs (reducible in some states). Trupanion: not stated as a single US number on the FAQ we fetched.
  • Lookback / cure: Trupanion describes an 18-month lookback and a permanent allergy example. Lemonade and Embrace describe a 12-month symptom-free path for some temporary conditions, not for ligament/chronic.
  • Accident-only: Embrace publishes one. Lemonade and Trupanion pages we fetched do not.
  • Wellness: Lemonade optional preventative packages. Embrace optional non-insurance Wellness Rewards (not standalone). Trupanion: no wellness add-on we verified.

Fetch, Pets Best, Spot

CarrierEnrollment ageWaiting periods9yo Frenchie + ACL
FetchFetch’s coverage page: pets of every age from 6 weeks. No upper-age limit stated on that page. Premiums typically rise with age — verify on the quote form.Fetch’s public coverage pages: no waiting period for accidents (new injuries on or after the effective date, described as 1 day after you sign up). Illness waiting period of up to 15 days. Optional wellness: no waiting period. Verify on the quote form and the issued policy. Terms vary by state.No upper age on Fetch’s coverage page. A 9-year-old Frenchie can typically start a quote. Fetch lists torn ligament as incurable. Bilateral orthopedic: the other knee is typically treated as pre-existing too.Get a quote from Fetch
Pets BestPets Best FAQ: enroll from 7 weeks. No upper age limit. Senior dogs and cats get the same accident-and-illness product types as puppies, subject to pre-existing exclusions.Waiting periods vary by state. A Pets Best sample policy booklet (MN) lists 14 days for illnesses, 3 days for injuries, and 6 months for cruciate ligament events. Pets Best also publishes a Waiting Period Health Assessment form (dated 03/2025) that may waive waits if a qualifying exam is done 3 days before or 7 days after the effective date. Verify on the quote form and the issued policy. Terms vary by state.No upper age. A 9-year-old can typically quote accident-and-illness unless the application routes to Accident Only because of listed chronic conditions. A documented ACL is pre-existing. Cruciate events also have a long waiting period on the sample policy. Bilateral rules often take the other knee with it.Get a quote from Pets Best
SpotSpot’s older-pets page: no upper age limit; pets 8 weeks and older can enroll and keep coverage. A healthy 10-year-old dog can obtain coverage; pre-existing conditions documented before enrollment are excluded.Spot’s California insurer disclosure (fetched Aug 2026): 14-day accident and illness waiting period on the first policy period; ligament and knee conditions also 14 days. Conditions during a wait are pre-existing. A Waiting Period Health Assessment may modify the wait. Other states may differ. Verify on the quote form and the issued policy. Terms vary by state.No upper age on Spot’s older-pets page. A 9-year-old can typically quote. Ligament and knee conditions are excluded from Spot’s 180-day curable path and are treated as bilateral.Get a quote from Spot

We are not picking one

If the animal has a documented ACL, every carrier in this table excludes it on the public pages we fetched. The comparison that matters is enrollment age, wait length, and whether a curable-condition rule could ever apply to something else on the record. Run the quote forms.

Sources (fetched 30 August 2026)

Facts below come from official public carrier pages. Waiting periods, age caps, and premiums change by state and over time. Label anything operational as stale-prone: verify on the quote form.